The 6 best dog subscription boxes for toys and treats

Best overall: PupJoy

PupJoy secured nan apical spot connected our database because of its assortment and quality. Pet parents tin take from pre-built and customizable boxes for small, medium, and ample dogs. Every container is filled pinch high-quality toys and treats, and location are pre-built boxes specifically for dense chewers. The boxes whitethorn see plush and tug toys, rubber chews, balls, and puzzles.

We received a pre-built container pinch a ample duck tug artifact and a squeaky bouncy ball. Our tester pup loved playing pinch some toys, and they held up to her reliable chewing and tugging, which was a happy surprise. The treats were a hit, too, and she gobbled them up each clip we offered them. 

While nan packaged treats had nutrition accusation printed connected their labels, nan bully sticks lacked akin details, thing we for illustration to see. We besides wish location were themed options for illustration vacation and seasonal boxes.

Best for chewers: Bullymake

Bullymake is hands down nan champion subscription container for fierce chewers. Inside each box, you'll find immoderate operation of tug, treat-dispensing, and chew toys made from ballistic nylon, nylon, rubber, and rope. Boxes see exclusive Bullymake treats, and you tin besides expect to spot treats from different brands thrown successful occasionally. 

Our tester pup is simply a pit operation pinch a beardown jaw and a stronger determination to destruct each her toys. Yet she couldn't break immoderate of nan Bullymake toys. We loved really durable and versatile these selections were. We received chew, tug, and puzzle toys that made for exceptionally varied play. The items successful nan container besides followed an adorable Halloween theme, which was nosy to unpack. 

Potential subscribers should cognize that Bullymake is much costly than galore competitors. The boxes sometimes see difficult nylon toys, and we counsel avoiding thing you can't indent pinch your fingernail. If you scheme to springiness your canine particularly difficult toys, we urge first talking to your vet astir nan consequence of teeth damage. You tin besides cheque retired our recommendations for nan best canine toys for fierce chewers for fantabulous options.

Best themed: BarkBox

One of nan original subscription boxes for dogs, BarkBox has made a sanction for itself pinch its clever artifact and dainty boxes that are a awesome action for astir dogs. Toys are designed astir circumstantial monthly themes for illustration celebrated movies and TV shows, holidays, and seasons.

We liked that nan toys we received often served 2 functions, specified arsenic being some a tug and puzzle toy. This helped america get much usage from toys that weren't very durable. The treats were besides good received by our dog: The oatmeal and cheesy soft baked biscuits saw a fewer tail wags each clip we opened nan packages. 

With BarkBox, nan spotlight is chiefly connected nan toys. The boxes often incorporate nan aforesaid treats, truthful don't expect a different action each time. Because nan toys aren't very durable, we don't urge BarkBox for dogs who are powerful chewers. The institution has a Super Chewer Box, which you tin publication astir successful our afloat BarkBox review.

Best budget: PupBox

The champion canine subscription boxes tin beryllium costly, but PupBox is simply a awesome action if you're looking to walk little but get more. Our different picks, speech from BarkBox, costs anyplace from $2 to $22 much per period pinch a yearlong subscription, truthful you'll prevention astatine slightest $24 a twelvemonth — and person an other accessory and training guideline each month. Every container comes pinch 5 to 7 items, including toys, treats, and an accessory for illustration a bandana aliases leash. PupBox selects toys based connected your dog's age, truthful puppies whitethorn person teething toys, while boxes for big dogs incorporate items for illustration larger tug toys.  

The toys we received successful our Halloween-themed container were well-designed. The shot chew artifact was sturdy and sewage our tester canine excited, acknowledgment to its squeaker. The cloth mummy held up to galore aggravated tug sessions. In statement pinch nan spooky theme, our accessory was a skeleton-print bandana. PupJoy includes a training paper successful each box, which is simply a bully touch pinch adjuvant tips for bonding pinch your dog.

The dainty action was mean compared to different subscription boxes. The exclusive Full Moon Munchies were barren and a spot old contempt their airtight packaging.

Best for a bully cause: Rescue Box

If you want to dainty your canine and lend to a bully origin while you do it, Rescue Box is nan measurement to go. You tin acquisition this container astatine nan Animal Rescue Site by Greater Good, a nonprofit statement that donates a information of income to various animal shelters. These proceeds spell toward providing nutrient and attraction for nan animals astatine nan shelters.

We loved nan toys successful this box: We received 2 durable stuffed toys — a moose and a soda plush artifact — that held up amazingly good to Lyla's unsmooth play style. The toys were besides minimally stuffed, making cleanup a breeze erstwhile she inevitably tore them apart. 

We'd for illustration to spot nutrition accusation included pinch each of nan treats. While we yet felt comfortable giving them to our dog, different pet parents whitethorn not consciousness nan aforesaid way.

Best for nutrient sensitivities: Pooch Perks

Pet owners shopping for pups pinch nutrient sensitivities and allergies whitethorn person trouble uncovering nan champion canine subscription box, arsenic galore services don't connection this level of customization. That's wherever Pooch Perks comes in. This container provides an awesome array of customization options: You tin take durable aliases plush toys for your pup's container and petition circumstantial ingredients beryllium included aliases excluded from treats. The boxes are tailored to your dog's size, and location is simply a wide scope of prepaid subscription options.

Upon receiving our Pooch Box, we instantly liked nan included treats. The marque does a awesome occupation of sourcing a wide assortment of nan best canine treats for your pup, and our trial canine loved nan beef jerky chews, biscuits, and specialty chickenhearted jerky chew tucked successful nan box.

We tested nan plush toys box, and while they were celebrated pinch our dog, they weren't nan champion we've seen. They were easy to harm erstwhile we simulated lighter play earlier handing them complete to our ace chewer. A fewer threads popped retired of 1 of nan toys erstwhile we scratched it pinch a meal fork. However, nan marque does connection a durable artifact container for much fierce pups.

What to look for successful canine subscription boxes

Before buying a canine subscription box, see a fewer factors. Most boxes see toys and treats, but immoderate are specifically designed for mini aliases ample breeds and whitethorn not beryllium suitable for each pup. The experts we consulted besides provided immoderate proposal connected what to look for successful a container for your dog. 

Treats: Treats shouldn't dress up much than 10% of your dog's diet, according to Dr. Mondrian Contreras, veterinarian and proprietor of Carol Stream Animal Hospital. We urge slow integrating subscription container treats into your dog's fare to guarantee they don't person immoderate adverse reactions, for illustration an upset stomach. We besides urge treats pinch nan ingredients and nutritional accusation printed connected nan explanation truthful you cognize precisely what you're feeding your dog.

Toys: Erin Askeland, a master canine trainer and animal wellness and behavioral master for Camp Bow Wow, says nan best canine toys will disagree for each pup, but generally, sturdier toys are better. She besides prefers toys that deficiency further parts, specified arsenic mini sewn-on buttons and googly eyes that are easy to swallow.

Our experts besides counsel against toys you can't indent pinch a fingernail, arsenic they tin harm a dog's teeth. For ace chewers, durable rubber is simply a bully action that tin often withstand beardown jaws, but smaller pups will person much problem pinch these heavy-duty toys. Ideally, nan champion canine subscription boxes supply options for pups large and small, pinch due toys for their size and chewing ability. 

Individual preferences: The champion canine subscription container is nan 1 that suits your pup's needs and preferences. Toys, especially, tin beryllium challenging to select. "Sometimes there's a small spot of proceedings and correction involved," says Askeland. We urge starting pinch a one-time container acquisition earlier committing to a subscription.

How we tested nan champion canine subscription boxes

We tested 7 celebrated canine subscription boxes that included some toys and treats. While a fewer brands sent america much than 1 box, we evaluated only 1 container from each work for this guide.

Quality and durability of toys: Before handing nan toys complete to our 50-pound ace chewer, Lyla, we tested each one's durability pinch a fork to spot really it would apt guidelines up to a smaller canine who chews little intensely. We besides timed really agelong it took Lyla to destruct nan toys. Since she chews truthful aggressively, boxes pinch toys that lasted a fewer days scored highly. Toys besides scored points for reliable materials for illustration nylon mesh, which is longer-lasting than polyester fabric. 

Toy safety: We debar exceptionally difficult toys aliases items filled pinch mini bits of integrative that tin airs a choking hazard. For this reason, we gave other points to toys we could indent pinch a fingernail and ones filled pinch soft stuffing alternatively of crinkle material. In our reviews, we've disclosed whether immoderate toys didn't meet these standards.

Quality and information of treats: Treats pinch transparent nutrition and constituent accusation scored highly, while treats pinch small to nary accusation did not execute good successful our evaluation. While we besides considered our tester dog's dainty preferences, we gave much weight to nan clear nutrition information.

Variety: The boxes we urge see thing for each dog. Boxes pinch a assortment of toys, specified arsenic tug toys, balls aliases squeaky toys, and puzzle aliases treat-dispensing toys, scored good successful our testing. We besides evaluated dainty variety. Because astir boxes contained a akin operation of biscuits and mini meaty bites, treats factored into our information less. 

Price: We compared each box's contents to akin products sold astatine ample pet retailers. We compared nan per-box value points of single, six-month, and 12-month subscription plans to a period of artifact and dainty purchases astatine nan retailers. We besides noted really agelong these toys and treats lasted compared to what we usually bargain for our dog. Boxes that didn't connection amended worth were scored lower.

Packaging: We deducted points for boxes pinch excessive packaging. This included individually wrapped toys and treats, oversized integrative merchandise tags, and filling specified arsenic insubstantial paper. 

Giving backmost and sustainability: We sought retired boxes pinch verifiable ties to shelters aliases sustainability initiatives.

Theme: For themed boxes, we evaluated whether nan taxable was cohesive among nan toys and treats.

Dog subscription container FAQs

Are canine container subscriptions worthy it?

It depends. One of nan champion canine subscription boxes could beryllium a cleanable fresh for your pup, depending connected their preferences, but because astir boxes are pre-built, it mightiness beryllium difficult to get precisely what your canine likes. If you shop for toys and treats yourself, you whitethorn beryllium much apt to find toys they emotion alternatively than gambling connected a box. However, nan subscription boxes we tested were each coagulated options, and our tester canine enjoyed each nan treats and toys successful her boxes. For us, these boxes are much than worthy it. 

Which canine subscription is nan best?

The champion canine subscription container contains interactive, safe toys that promote you to play pinch your pup. These toys whitethorn beryllium treat-dispensing puzzles, durable tug toys, aliases elemental plushies, but they should beryllium free of small, easy-to-swallow pieces and very difficult plastic. Askeland says that playtime pinch your canine is essential, and while you whitethorn not request to actively play pinch thing for illustration a puzzle toy, making clip for your canine each time is bully for some of you. "Even if you tin do 5 to 10 minutes of play a time pinch you really physically playing pinch them, that's conscionable a awesome point to do for them, for their brains, and a bully break for you, too," says Askeland. 

Is location a canine subscription container for aggregate dogs?

If you person a family pinch much than 1 dog, we urge purchasing aggregate boxes to forestall title complete toys and treats. But if your dogs happily stock their toys and treats, 1 container whitethorn beryllium suitable.