4 minggu yang lalu
Aston Villa secured a historical triumph connected nan return of Champions League shot to Villa Park connected Wednesday night, beating German giants Bayern Munich 1-0.
Jhon Duran proved he is nan King of Chaos for Unai Emery arsenic he scored aft coming disconnected nan chair erstwhile again, netting precocious connected arsenic his broadside held connected for a daze victory, but really did he rate?
Emiliano Martinez, meanwhile, was nan prima of nan show arsenic he came to nan rescue precocious on, and his capacity earns him a coagulated standing from Mail Sport's TOM COLLOMOSSE astatine Villa Park.
As for Villa's opponents, though, it was nan aforesaid aged communicative for Harry Kane - who grew disappointment successful nan crippled - and that's reflected successful his rating.
Read connected to spot really each subordinate progressive successful Thursday's European necktie fared successful our lucifer ratings.
Jhon Duran (left) came disconnected nan chair to people nan winning extremity for Aston Villa connected a historical European night
Villa hit Bayern Munich 1-0 astatine Villa Park successful their first location Champions League lucifer of nan season
Bayern huffed and puffed but were incapable to break down Villa's defence connected a reliable evening for nan German club
Aston Villa (4-4-2)
Emiliano Martinez - 8.5
Had small to do successful nan first half until he leapt to his correct to extremity Michael Olise's swerving effort complete past made moreover amended stops from Serge Gnabry and Kane precocious on.
Ezri Konsa - 8
Up against specified a tricky customer successful Kingsley Coman, Konsa showed what a good one-on-one defender he is – moreover though he dislikes playing correct back.
Diego Carlos - 6.5
Not galore centre backs would take to look Kane alternatively than Liam Delap but he had an easier clip against nan England skipper than he did against nan Ipswich man past Sunday.
Pau Torres - 7.5
Disappointed to spot his extremity chalked disconnected for offside, nan Spaniard enjoys nan European stage, wherever his occasionally beingness fragility is seldom exposed. Fine shot for Duran's goal.
Lucas Digne - 7
The near backmost had a bully commencement successful some onslaught and defence though Villa's precocious statement intends nary separator for correction and location were a mates of hairy moments.
Goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez was nan prima of nan show for Villa pinch 2 large stops precocious on
Pau Torres thought he had fixed Villa nan lead successful nan first half, but his onslaught was ruled retired for offside
Jaden Philogene - 7.5
Emery showed immense spot by starting him complete Leon Bailey and Philogene repaid him pinch a capacity of awesome maturity.
Amadou Onana - 6.5
Had his hands connected his knees astatine 1 shape successful nan first half aft getting done a immense magnitude of activity successful nan centre of midfield.
Youri Tielemans - 7.5
Villa's champion subordinate during nan early weeks of this season, nan Belgian delivered again, pinch 1 superb rotation distant from Joshua Kimmich nan highlight.
Jacob Ramsey - 6
Switched disconnected by straying offside successful nan move that meant Torres' onslaught was ruled retired for offside and past had to travel disconnected injured midway done nan first half.
Morgan Rogers - 7
Imprecise during nan opening exchanges, he nevertheless grew into nan crippled and was soon testing Bayern by picking nan shot up heavy and charging astatine their backmost four.
Ollie Watkins - 6.5
Drew 2 fouls from Dayot Upamecano that should person seen nan Bayern man prime up 2 bookings. Made judge he utilized nan fewer chances he had to origin nan visitors problems.
Jacob Ramsey switched disconnected successful nan build up to nan disallowed extremity earlier leaving early done injury
Ollie Watkins caused nan visitors problems arsenic he led nan statement erstwhile again successful Champions League
Substitutes
Leon Bailey (for Ramsey 27) - 5
Gave nan shot distant doubly soon aft coming connected and was brutally hauled disconnected conscionable 33 minutes later.
Ian Maatsen (for Bailey, 60) - 6
Sent connected by Uani Emery to play successful beforehand of Digne and statement up Villa's left-hand side.
Ross Barkley (for Onana, 60) - 6
Onana had put successful a immense displacement and looked to beryllium struggling erstwhile nan Englishman replaced him.
Jhon Duran (for Watkins, 70) - 7.5
In beforehand of nan early King, it was different nighttime to retrieve for Villa's very ain King of Chaos.
Manager
Unai Emery - 7
Instructed his squad to fto Bayern person nan shot for nan mostly of nan lucifer and make accelerated breaks erstwhile they regained nan ball. It astir worked.
Duran is Villa's very ain King of Chaos and erstwhile again delivered from nan substitutes bench
Manager Unai Emery erstwhile again showed his magic touch successful Europe, this clip pinch Aston Villa
Bayern Munich (3-1-3-3)
Manuel Neuer - 5
One dodgy walk went consecutive to Digne and had nan Villa fans urging their man to sprout from 70 yards. All astatine oversea for Torres' disallowed extremity and obscurity to beryllium seen for Duran's.
Joshua Kimmich - 7.5
Villa could not travel to grips pinch his passing aliases activity during nan early shape and he remains 1 of nan cleverest players successful nan European game.
Dayot Upamecano - 6
Struggled to grip Watkins and was fortunate not to beryllium sent off, someway escaping a booking for dragging down nan England guardant arsenic he tried to title clear.
Kim Min-jae - 6.5
Crucial leap astatine nan acold station to extremity Watkins heading Villa successful front. Solid successful defence but possibly not nan ball-playing centre backmost that Vincent Kompany needs for this style of play.
Manuel Neuer was each astatine oversea for Villa's disallowed extremity and obscurity to beryllium seen for nan 1 that stood
Despite ending up connected nan losing broadside Joshua Kimmich showed why he is 1 of nan cleverest players successful nan game
Aleksandar Pavlovic - 6.5
Required to nexus defence and midfield erstwhile Bayern had nan shot and protect his backmost statement erstwhile they did not, he did a broadly competent job.
Konrad Laimer - 7
Showed terrific power down nan Bayern correct and his nonstop moving often had Villa back-pedalling, though he was little assured erstwhile asked to defend.
Michael Olise - 6.5
The erstwhile Crystal Palace man recovered himself connected nan fringes of nan crippled for nan astir portion though he came truthful adjacent to putting Bayern successful beforehand soon earlier half-time.
Alphonso Davies - 6.5
Tried to harvester pinch Coman successful nan first half but Konsa and Philogene did a good occupation connected them. Had fewer problems going nan different way.
Michael Olise recovered himself connected nan fringes for astir of nan crippled but came adjacent to putting his broadside successful front
Serge Gnabry disappointment Kane erstwhile he tried to hit Martinez from a tight angel pinch nan England skipper waiting
Serge Gnabry - 5.5
With Kane waiting for nan tap-in, he tried alternatively to hit Martinez from a tight perspective and blasted into nan crowd. Thwarted again by nan Argentina prima astatine nan end.
Harry Kane - 5.5
Would person expected to origin Torres and Carlos much problems than he did.
Kingsley Coman - 5.5
Never managed to find a measurement past Konsa and was often forced inside, wherever he besides had small joy. Hooked for Musiala astatine nan interval.
Kane would person hoped to person caused Diego Carlos and Pau Torres much problems than he did backmost successful his homeland
Substitutes
Jamal Musiala (for Coman, 46) - 6
Surprisingly near retired of nan starting XI, he tried to springiness Bayern thing other successful an attacking midfield role.
Leroy Sane (for Olise, 67) - 6
More of a nonstop subordinate than Olise, nan erstwhile Manchester City man gave Digne and Maatsen plentifulness to deliberation about.
Joao Palhinha (for Pavlovic, 76) - 6
The summertime signing from Fulham was asked to execute nan aforesaid tasks arsenic Pavlovic.
Mathys Tel (for Gnabry, 86)
Leon Goretzka (for Kim, 86)
Vincent Kompany's broadside play immoderate fabulous shot yet look shaky astatine nan back, peculiarly from group pieces
Manager
Vincent Kompany - 6
His squad play immoderate fabulous shot yet they look shaky astatine nan back, peculiarly from group pieces, and this could extremity them going each nan way.
Referee
Radu Peterscu (Romania) - 5
Attendance
42,401
English (US) · 
Indonesian (ID) ·